OpenAI asks a judge to toss all 41 Tumbler Ridge shooting lawsuits, arguing ChatGPT conversations have First Amendment protection

by | Nov 20, 2026 | Latest E-commerce News & Updates

OpenAI and CEO Sam Altman asked a California federal court to dismiss all 41 lawsuits tied to February’s Tumbler Ridge school shooting, arguing that talking with ChatGPT is protected speech under the First Amendment, like books and video games. The suits, brought by the B.C. government, the school district, survivors, and families of the eight people killed, say OpenAI should have called police once it flagged shooter Jesse Van Rootselaar’s account over gun violence, as two staff reviewers had recommended. OpenAI’s motion says it owed police no warning, that ChatGPT is a service rather than a defective product, and that California’s duty-to-protect rule for psychotherapists doesn’t cover it. OpenAI also wants Van Rootselaar’s chat history kept sealed, which the B.C. government opposes.

Paul Drecksler is the founder and editor of Shopifreaks, covering the most important stories in e-commerce.

Companies: OpenAI

Never miss important e-commerce news

Our weekly newsletter is read religiously by 20,000+ e-commerce professionals.

Loading...